Experienced California Insurance Attorneys for Policyholders Facing Coverage Disputes
McGonigle Law represents California policyholders in disputes with insurance companies over denied, delayed, terminated, and underpaid claims. Our insurance attorneys handle disability insurance, coverage disputes, and other complex insurance matters.

When Your Insurance Company Doesn't Hold Up Its End of the Policy
You paid for insurance because you expected protection when you needed it.
Then a serious loss happens. You become unable to work. Your business suffers a major interruption. Your property is damaged. A claim is submitted—and instead of receiving the coverage you expected, you find yourself fighting with the insurance company.
The insurer may deny the claim entirely. It may delay a decision for months, pay only a fraction of the loss, terminate benefits that were already being paid, or rely on exclusions and policy language to argue that coverage does not apply.
McGonigle Law represents California individuals, professionals, businesses, and other policyholders in significant insurance disputes. We examine the policy, the claim, the insurer's reasoning, and the evidence supporting the loss to determine what coverage may be available and how the dispute should be addressed.
Types of Insurance Disputes We Handle
Insurance disputes can arise under many different types of policies. Depending on the matter, our attorneys may handle disputes involving:
Disability Insurance
When an illness or injury prevents someone from working, disability insurance benefits can become an essential source of income.
We represent policyholders in disputes involving denied disability claims, terminated benefits, disagreements over whether the insured meets the policy's definition of disability, and other private disability insurance issues.
Long-Term Disability Insurance
Long-term disability claims can involve substantial benefits paid over an extended period of time.
Disputes may arise over medical evidence, occupational requirements, policy definitions, continuing eligibility for benefits, or an insurer's decision to terminate benefits after initially approving a claim.
Property Insurance
Property insurance disputes can arise after fires, water damage, natural disasters, and other significant losses.
Coverage disagreements may involve whether the loss is covered, the extent of the damage, applicable exclusions, valuation of the claim, or the amount the insurance company is willing to pay.
Homeowners Insurance
A serious loss involving a home can create both financial and personal disruption.
Homeowners may encounter disputes involving coverage for property damage, repair or replacement costs, additional expenses, policy exclusions, or the insurer's valuation of a covered loss.
Commercial and Business Insurance
Businesses purchase insurance to protect against risks that can threaten their property, operations, and financial stability.
Commercial insurance disputes may involve property losses, coverage questions, business-related claims, policy exclusions, and disagreements concerning the insurer's obligations under the policy.
Business Interruption Insurance
When a covered event forces a business to suspend or reduce operations, the financial consequences can extend well beyond physical property damage.
Business interruption disputes may involve lost income, continuing expenses, the period of interruption, financial documentation, policy interpretation, and disagreements over the amount owed.
Other Insurance Coverage Disputes
Insurance policies vary considerably, and coverage disputes are not limited to one particular type of insurance.
McGonigle Law evaluates complex insurance matters involving significant coverage questions, disputed policy interpretations, and substantial financial losses.

Denied, Delayed, Terminated or Underpaid?
An insurance dispute does not always begin with a formal and full denial letter.
Sometimes the problem is that the insurance company keeps requesting additional information without making a decision – thereby unreasonably delaying the claim. In other cases, the insurer acknowledges coverage but disputes the value of the claim. A policyholder receiving ongoing benefits may suddenly be told that payments are ending.
We represent policyholders facing issues such as:
- Complete claim denials
- Unreasonable claim delays
- Termination of ongoing benefits
- Underpayment of covered losses
- Disputes over the value of a claim
- Disagreements over policy exclusions
- Disputes over definitions contained in the policy
- Requests for extensive additional documentation
- Conflicting interpretations of insurance policy language
The Insurance Policy Is the Starting Point
A policy may contain multiple coverage provisions, definitions, exclusions, endorsements, limitations, conditions, and exceptions. A single provision can significantly affect whether coverage exists or how much may be payable.
That is why our review begins with the complete insurance policy—not simply the insurer's explanation of what it believes the policy covers.
Our attorneys compare the policy language with the circumstances of the claim, the documentation submitted by the policyholder, and the reasons the insurance company has given for denying, limiting, delaying, or terminating benefits.
When the Insurance Company Values Your Loss Differently
The policyholder and insurance company may disagree about the extent of a loss, the amount necessary to repair or replace damaged property, lost income, continuing expenses, disability benefits, or another component of the claim.
These disputes can require more than simply reviewing the policy. Financial records, medical evidence, property documentation, estimates, expert opinions, claim communications, and other evidence may become important depending on the type of insurance involved.

What to Keep When an Insurance Dispute Develops
If you are having problems with an insurance claim, maintaining a complete claim file can make it much easier to understand what happened.
Important records may include:
The complete insurance policy, including endorsements
Policy declarations
The original claim submission
Denial or termination letters
Emails and letters from the insurance company
Communications with adjusters or claims representatives
Proof of loss and supporting documentation
Payment records
Property estimates or damage documentation
Medical records relating to disability claims
Financial records relating to business losses
A timeline of significant claim communications
Different types of claims require different evidence, but the goal is the same: preserve the information showing what was claimed, what the insurer was provided, and why the insurer took its position.
A Dispute With Your Insurer Can Become a Serious Legal Matter
When substantial benefits, property, income, or business losses are at stake, McGonigle Law helps level that playing field.
Our attorneys analyze the coverage, organize the relevant evidence, identify the issues driving the dispute, and determine an appropriate strategy for pursuing the benefits available under the policy.
Depending on the circumstances, that may involve direct negotiations with the insurer, mediation, arbitration, or litigation.
Talk to McGonigle Law About Your Insurance Dispute
If an insurance company is refusing to provide the coverage or benefits you believe your policy provides, you do not have to rely solely on the insurer's interpretation of your claim.
McGonigle Law represents California policyholders in complex disputes involving disability insurance, long-term disability benefits, property and homeowners coverage, commercial insurance, business interruption claims, and other significant insurance matters.
Contact McGonigle Law at (800) 713-5260 to discuss your insurance dispute.

