Attorney Malpractice

Experienced Representation for Clients Harmed by Attorney Negligence

Fire trucks outside the Boyle Heights warehouse after the fire
Case image — optional CMS field

Attorneys are required to meet professional standards when representing their clients. McGonigle Law represents individuals and businesses harmed by attorney negligence and professional malpractice in California legal matters.

California Attorney Malpractice Lawyers

Clients rely on attorneys to protect important legal, financial, business, and personal interests. When an attorney fails to meet applicable professional standards, the consequences can be significant.

For more than 40 years, Timothy D. McGonigle has represented clients in complex California litigation. Legal malpractice is a core focus of his practice, including claims involving serious attorney errors, professional negligence, and substantial financial or legal harm.

McGonigle Law represents individuals, businesses, professionals, and other clients in attorney malpractice matters throughout California.

What Is Attorney Malpractice?

An unfavorable result does not necessarily mean that an attorney committed malpractice. Lawyers cannot guarantee the outcome of a lawsuit, transaction, negotiation, or other legal matter.

A legal malpractice claim requires a more careful analysis of the attorney's conduct and its consequences. Depending on the circumstances, that analysis may involve whether the attorney failed to meet the applicable professional standard, whether that failure caused harm, and what damages resulted.

This distinction is important. McGonigle Law evaluates potential attorney malpractice claims based on the underlying facts, the work performed by the former attorney, and the effect the alleged error had on the client's legal or financial interests.

Examples of Attorney Malpractice

Attorney malpractice can arise in many different circumstances. Potential claims may involve allegations that an attorney:

  • Missed a statute of limitations or other critical deadline
  • Failed to timely file necessary documents
  • Failed to properly investigate or prepare a case
  • Made serious errors during litigation
  • Mishandled evidence or significant legal issues
  • Failed to communicate material information
  • Failed to communicate a settlement offer
  • Provided negligent advice concerning a settlement
  • Had an improper or undisclosed conflict of interest
  • Mishandled important financial or property interests
  • Made serious errors in a family law matter
  • Failed to properly address a QDRO or retirement asset
  • Committed other acts or omissions that caused substantial harm

Not every mistake constitutes actionable malpractice. The nature of the error, the underlying matter, causation, and the resulting harm must be considered together.

The "Case Within a Case"

Legal malpractice litigation can be particularly complex because evaluating the former attorney's conduct may require a detailed examination of the original legal matter.

For example, when a lawyer allegedly mishandles a lawsuit, determining whether the error caused damage may require evaluating what likely would have occurred if the underlying case had been handled differently.

This is sometimes referred to as the "case within a case."

The analysis may require reviewing:

  • Pleadings and motions
  • Evidence and discovery
  • Depositions
  • Court orders and judgments
  • Settlement negotiations
  • Expert opinions
  • Critical filing deadlines
  • Trial or arbitration proceedings
  • The claims and defenses in the underlying matter

The ability to understand and evaluate the underlying litigation can therefore be an important part of handling an attorney malpractice case.

Missed Deadlines and Litigation Errors

Some attorney mistakes can have immediate and significant consequences.

Missing a statute of limitations or another critical filing deadline may affect a client's ability to pursue a claim or preserve an important legal right. Serious errors involving motions, discovery, evidence, settlement, or trial preparation can also affect the course of litigation.

Even when an error appears clear, however, a malpractice claim may still require analysis of whether the mistake caused the client's loss.

McGonigle Law evaluates the attorney's conduct together with the underlying case to determine the significance of the alleged error.

Attorney Malpractice Involving Settlements

Settlement decisions can have lasting financial and legal consequences.

Potential malpractice issues may arise when an attorney allegedly fails to communicate a settlement offer, provides negligent advice concerning a proposed settlement, mishandles negotiations, or makes another significant error affecting a client's settlement rights.

These cases can require careful review of attorney-client communications, settlement offers, negotiations, the value and strength of the underlying matter, and the circumstances surrounding the client's decision.

Family Law Attorney Malpractice

Errors in divorce and family law matters can affect property rights, child custody, support obligations, settlements, and retirement assets.

McGonigle Law maintains a dedicated Family Law Malpractice practice addressing potential attorney negligence involving custody matters, settlements, child support, missed deadlines, QDROs, and other significant family law issues.

More Than 40 Years of California Litigation Experience

Attorney malpractice cases require an understanding of both professional standards and the litigation or legal matter underlying the claim.

Timothy D. McGonigle brings more than four decades of California litigation experience to the firm's legal malpractice practice. His experience includes evaluating attorney conduct from multiple perspectives, including his work as an attorney and as an expert witness in matters involving legal malpractice, attorney professional standards, and attorney fee disputes.

That depth of experience is central to McGonigle Law's approach to attorney malpractice litigation.

Frequently Asked Questions About Attorney Malpractice

How Long Do I Have to File a Legal Malpractice Claim Against My Attorney in California?

California legal malpractice claims are generally subject to a statute of limitations under California Code of Civil Procedure section 340.6. In many cases, an action must be filed within one year after the client discovers, or reasonably should have discovered, the facts constituting the attorney's alleged wrongful act or omission, or within four years from the date of the wrongful act or omission, whichever occurs first.

However, determining the actual deadline can be complicated. California law provides circumstances that may toll or affect the limitations period, including certain situations involving continued representation by the attorney or when the client has not yet sustained actual injury.

Because missing the applicable deadline can prevent a client from pursuing an otherwise valid legal malpractice claim, anyone who believes an attorney may have caused them harm should have the matter evaluated promptly.

Can I Sue My Attorney for Making a Mistake?

Potentially. Whether a mistake supports a legal malpractice claim depends on the attorney's conduct, the applicable professional standard, the underlying matter, causation, and the resulting harm.

Does Losing My Case Mean My Lawyer Committed Malpractice?

No. An unfavorable outcome by itself does not establish attorney malpractice. The circumstances surrounding the representation and the reason for the loss must be evaluated.

What if My Attorney Missed a Statute of Limitations?

A missed statute of limitations can have serious consequences. Whether it supports a malpractice claim depends on the underlying case, the effect of the missed deadline, causation, damages, and other circumstances.

What Documents Should I Keep?

Relevant materials may include the attorney-client fee agreement, pleadings, court orders, judgments, motions, correspondence, settlement communications, billing records, deposition transcripts, arbitration documents, and other records relating to the underlying matter.

Speak With an Experienced California Attorney Malpractice Lawyer

If you believe a former attorney's professional negligence caused substantial harm to your legal or financial interests, the underlying representation should be carefully evaluated.

For more than 40 years, Timothy D. McGonigle has litigated complex matters in California. McGonigle Law brings that experience to serious attorney malpractice claims involving lawyers and law firms throughout the state.

Contact McGonigle Law at (800) 713-5260 to discuss your potential attorney malpractice matter.

Complex cases deserve a clear path forward

For more than 40 years, McGonigle Law has represented individuals, families, and businesses in complex civil litigation. The firm evaluates each Mass Tort matter individually and explains the available path forward in plain language.

Timothy D. McGonigle portrait
Timothy D. McGonigle
Founding Attorney  
40+ Years of Trial Experience

Your Attorney Failed You. Don't Let the Clock Run Out Too.

California's statute of limitations for legal malpractice is strict. Every day you wait is a day closer to losing your right to recover. Contact McGonigle Law today for a free, confidential consultation — we'll tell you honestly whether you have a case.

Phone icon
Phone
Email icon
Email
Location pin icon
Office