$6.1 Million Verdict Against Centro Medico Community Clinic For Wrongful Termination Of Whistle Blower
McGonigle Law, working with Braunstein & Braunstein, P.C., obtained a $6.1 million jury verdict for Dr. Saied Ibrahim Saied and Dr. Nagy Philips Bebawy against Centro Medico Community Clinic, Inc. The physicians alleged that they were terminated in retaliation for reporting unlawful and exploitative practices at the nonprofit clinic.

McGonigle Law, working in conjunction with Braunstein & Braunstein, P.C., obtained a $6.1 million jury verdict on behalf of two physicians in a wrongful termination and retaliation case against Centro Medico Community Clinic, Inc.
The verdict followed a February 2017 jury trial involving Dr. Saied Ibrahim Saied and Dr. Nagy Philips Bebawy, who alleged that they were terminated after reporting improper and unlawful practices at the nonprofit medical clinic.
Timothy D. McGonigle served as lead counsel.
What Was the Centro Medico Case About?
Dr. Bebawy and Dr. Saied were physicians associated with Centro Medico Community Clinic and became involved in disputes concerning its management and treatment of patients.
The plaintiffs alleged that they suffered retaliation after reporting practices they believed violated legal and organizational requirements.
What Did the Physicians Report?
- Turning away patients who could not afford treatment;
- Ordering allegedly medically unnecessary tests;
- Charging additional amounts for certain services;
- Allowing a non-physician to exercise responsibilities associated with the Medical Director role;
- Excluding physicians from management and oversight functions; and
- Other allegedly improper management practices.
Dr. Nagy Bebawy's Dispute With the Clinic
According to McGonigle Law's case materials, Dr. Bebawy was intended to serve as Medical Director and later became involved in disputes concerning management control, medical staffing, and clinic oversight.
He alleged that his salary was reduced and that he was subsequently terminated after challenging the clinic's practices.
Dr. Saied's Whistleblower Allegations
Dr. Saied alleged that he reported clinic practices to the California Medical Board and pursued litigation concerning conduct he believed was unlawful.
He alleged that his hours and salary were reduced before he was ultimately terminated.
What Did the Jury Decide?
The matter proceeded to a jury trial in February 2017. McGonigle Law reports that the jury returned a verdict totaling approximately $6.1 million in favor of Dr. Saied and Dr. Bebawy.
What Happened With the Clinic After Trial?
After the first phase of a bifurcated trial addressing unfair business practice claims, the Honorable David L. Minning appointed a receiver for Centro Medico Community Clinic.
According to McGonigle Law's current verdict page, the receivership resulted in judicial supervision and operational changes at the clinic.
What Is a Receiver?
A receiver is a court-appointed neutral who may take control of or supervise property, operations, or an entity under circumstances authorized by law.
Why Is This Case Significant?
The case resulted in a substantial jury verdict for two physicians alleging wrongful termination and retaliation and also led to judicial oversight of the clinic through a receivership.
McGonigle Law's Role
Timothy D. McGonigle served as lead counsel, working in conjunction with Braunstein & Braunstein, P.C.
What Is Wrongful Termination for Whistleblowing?
California employees may have legal protections when they report conduct they reasonably believe violates the law or engage in other protected whistleblower activity.
The viability of a claim depends on the protected activity, adverse employment action, causal relationship, evidence, applicable statute, and damages.
Retaliation Can Include More Than Termination
Potential adverse actions may include reduced hours, reduced compensation, demotion, discipline, changes in responsibilities, exclusion from meetings, suspension, or termination.
Evidence in a Whistleblower Retaliation Case
Relevant evidence can include written complaints, emails, regulatory reports, HR records, performance reviews, pay records, management communications, termination documents, witness testimony, and a chronology of events.
The Case Also Involved Unfair Business Practice Claims
The Centro Medico litigation also involved allegations concerning clinic operations, which were addressed through a separate phase of the proceedings.
TopVerdict Recognition
McGonigle Law later reported that the Centro Medico result was recognized among significant California labor and employment jury verdicts.
McGonigle Law's Employment Litigation Practice
McGonigle Law represents employees in significant California employment disputes involving wrongful termination, retaliation, discrimination, harassment, whistleblower issues, and related claims.
The information contained herein is for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome.
Your Attorney Failed You. Don't Let the Clock Run Out Too.
California's statute of limitations for legal malpractice is strict. Every day you wait is a day closer to losing your right to recover. Contact McGonigle Law today for a free, confidential consultation — we'll tell you honestly whether you have a case.

