Ambiguity You Can't See on the Page: The Ninth Circuit Reaffirms California's Broad Extrinsic Evidence Rule in County of San Bernardino v. ICSOP

The Ninth Circuit's decision in County of San Bernardino v. Insurance Company of the State of Pennsylvania offers an important reminder for California coverage lawyers: even policy language that appears unambiguous on its face may contain a latent ambiguity revealed by extrinsic evidence. The decision also highlights the potential significance of industry history and an insurer's own claims files when interpreting legacy policies.

31 Aug 2026
Timothy D. McGonigle

The Ninth Circuit's decision in County of San Bernardino v. Insurance Company of the State of Pennsylvania offers an important reminder for California coverage lawyers: even policy language that appears clear on its face may become ambiguous when considered alongside relevant extrinsic evidence.

California's Broad Approach to Extrinsic Evidence

California courts have long taken a broad approach to the use of extrinsic evidence when interpreting contracts. In the insurance context, that principle can become particularly important when historical policies, industry practices, underwriting materials, insurer files, or other evidence provides context that cannot be seen from the policy language alone.

The central issue is not simply whether a policy provision appears ambiguous when read in isolation. Relevant evidence outside the policy may reveal a latent ambiguity and demonstrate that contractual language is reasonably susceptible to a meaning that would not otherwise be apparent from the face of the document.

County of San Bernardino v. ICSOP

In County of San Bernardino v. Insurance Company of the State of Pennsylvania, 174 F.4th 597 (9th Cir. 2026), the Ninth Circuit considered the interpretation of legacy umbrella insurance policies and reversed the district court's construction of the policies.

The decision reinforces the importance of considering relevant extrinsic evidence before concluding that insurance-policy language has only one reasonable interpretation.

Ambiguity That Does Not Appear on the Page

One of the most important lessons from the decision is that ambiguity is not necessarily something that can be identified simply by reading competing interpretations of a policy provision.

Extrinsic evidence may reveal a latent ambiguity—an uncertainty that becomes apparent only when the contractual language is considered in its historical, commercial, or factual context.

Why Insurer Files and Historical Evidence May Matter

For attorneys handling insurance coverage disputes, the decision underscores the potential importance of evidence such as insurer files, underwriting materials, historical communications, industry practices, and evidence concerning how particular policy language developed or was understood.

That evidence may provide important context when determining whether policy language is reasonably susceptible to the interpretation advanced by an insured.

Practical Implications for California Coverage Litigation

The decision is a reminder that attorneys should be cautious about treating the apparent clarity of policy language as the end of the interpretive analysis.

In appropriate cases, discovery directed toward the insurer's historical files and other relevant extrinsic evidence may materially affect how disputed policy language is interpreted.

For policyholders and their counsel, the broader lesson is straightforward: sometimes the most important ambiguity in an insurance policy is the ambiguity you cannot see on the page.

For more information or to schedule a confidential, free consultation, contact McGonigle Law at (800) 713-5260. 

This newsletter is for informational purposes only and is not legal advice. Every case is unique, and past results do not guarantee future outcomes.

Your Attorney Failed You. Don't Let the Clock Run Out Too.

California's statute of limitations for legal malpractice is strict. Every day you wait is a day closer to losing your right to recover. Contact McGonigle Law today for a free, confidential consultation — we'll tell you honestly whether you have a case.

Phone icon
Phone
Email icon
Email
Location pin icon
Office