Anti-SLAPP Victory Reinforces Broad Litigation Privilege Protections in Settlement-Related Claims
A California Court of Appeal decision in Norrenberg et al. v. Indus Investments, Inc. et al. reinforces the broad reach of California’s anti-SLAPP statute and litigation privilege for claims arising from lawsuits, settlement negotiations, and related communications. McGonigle Law, alongside Greenberg Traurig, represented Indus Investments, Royal Lush, LLC, and Tehmina Adaya in the appeal.

A recent California Court of Appeal decision delivered an important win for defendants facing retaliatory cross-complaints tied to litigation and settlement negotiations. In Norrenberg et al. v. Indus Investments, Inc. et al., the Second District Court of Appeal reversed the trial court and ordered the entire cross-complaint stricken under California’s anti-SLAPP statute, reaffirming the expansive reach of both Code of Civil Procedure section 425.16 and the litigation privilege.
McGonigle Law, alongside Greenberg Traurig, represented Indus Investments, Royal Lush, LLC, and Tehmina Adaya in the appeal.
The opinion is a significant reminder for litigators: claims arising from the filing of a lawsuit, settlement negotiations, or alleged settlement-related misrepresentations are often protected activity under California law.
The Underlying Dispute
The dispute stemmed from a 2021 employment-related settlement in which Indus paid former employee Sven Norrenberg and his wife to resolve threatened claims against the hotel and its ownership. Later, Indus filed suit alleging the settlement had been procured through fraud, collusion, and fabricated evidence involving the hotel’s former general manager.
In response, the defendants filed a cross-complaint asserting breach of contract, fraud-based claims, declaratory relief, and emotional distress. Their theory was straightforward: by filing the lawsuit challenging the settlement agreement, Indus had breached the agreement itself and allegedly misrepresented its intentions during settlement negotiations.
The trial court partially granted Indus’s anti-SLAPP motion but allowed several fraud-based claims to survive. The Court of Appeal disagreed and struck the entire cross-complaint.
Why the Opinion Matters
The court’s reasoning reinforces several key principles attorneys should pay close attention to:
1. Filing a Lawsuit Is Protected Activity
The court emphasized that claims based on the act of filing a complaint fall squarely within anti-SLAPP protection. The cross-complainants alleged Indus breached the settlement agreement by challenging it in litigation. That allegation alone triggered anti-SLAPP protections because the alleged wrongdoing was the filing of the lawsuit itself.
The opinion repeatedly stresses that litigants cannot avoid anti-SLAPP scrutiny merely by repackaging litigation conduct as breach of contract or fraud claims.
2. Settlement Negotiations Receive Broad Protection
Perhaps most notably, the court held that pre-litigation settlement negotiations are protected activity under section 425.16.
The cross-complainants argued they were fraudulently induced into entering the settlement agreement. But the court found those alleged misrepresentations occurred during settlement discussions in anticipation of litigation, making them protected petitioning activity.
For practitioners, the takeaway is clear: communications made during settlement negotiations—even before a complaint is filed—may trigger anti-SLAPP protections if litigation is seriously contemplated.
3. The Litigation Privilege Remains Extremely Powerful
The court also reaffirmed the expansive scope of California’s litigation privilege under Civil Code section 47(b). Even where claims are framed as fraud, negligent misrepresentation, or emotional distress, the privilege may bar liability entirely if the conduct at issue consists of litigation communications.
The court rejected attempts to characterize the claims as arising from “conduct” rather than protected communications. According to the opinion, the alleged wrongdoing could not be separated from the protected settlement communications and litigation activity.
Practical Implications for Litigators
This opinion serves as an important strategic reminder for attorneys handling business disputes, employment matters, and settlement enforcement cases:
- Anti-SLAPP motions remain a powerful early litigation tool.
- Settlement negotiations can constitute protected activity.
- Cross-complaints targeting litigation conduct face substantial risk.
- The litigation privilege continues to provide sweeping protection against derivative tort claims.
The decision also highlights the growing willingness of California appellate courts to apply anti-SLAPP protections broadly when claims are rooted in petitioning activity, even where plaintiffs attempt to frame their allegations as contractual or fraud-based disputes.
At McGonigle Law, we regularly represent businesses, attorneys, and professionals in complex litigation involving anti-SLAPP motions, legal malpractice, professional liability, and employment cases. If your firm or client is facing claims arising from protected litigation conduct, our team is available to assist. Call 1-(800) 713-5260 today!
Solutions
Your Attorney Failed You. Don't Let the Clock Run Out Too.
California's statute of limitations for legal malpractice is strict. Every day you wait is a day closer to losing your right to recover. Contact McGonigle Law today for a free, confidential consultation — we'll tell you honestly whether you have a case.

