California Code of Civil Procedure Section 231.7 Continues to Reshape Jury Selection in FEHA and Other Civil Cases
Beginning January 1, 2026, California Code of Civil Procedure section 231.7 fundamentally changed the way attorneys exercise and defend peremptory challenges in civil jury trials.

Beginning January 1, 2026, California Code of Civil Procedure section 231.7 fundamentally changed the way attorneys exercise and defend peremptory challenges in civil jury trials. While the statute initially received significant attention from trial lawyers, recent commentary suggests courts may already be narrowing the Legislature's intended reforms, making it more important than ever for practitioners to understand how the law is evolving. (Leginfo)
A recent Daily Journal article, "Saving California's Jury Bias Reform from Judicial Retreat," discusses concerns that some courts may be drifting away from the Legislature's clear intent behind section 231.7 by applying standards that resemble the older Batson/Wheeler framework. The article is an excellent read for any attorney preparing for jury selection in California civil litigation.
Read the article here.
Why Section 231.7 Matters
Section 231.7 was enacted to reduce both conscious and unconscious bias in jury selection. Unlike the traditional Batson/Wheeler procedure, the statute lowers the threshold for raising an objection and shifts greater responsibility to the attorney exercising the peremptory challenge. Once an objection is made, the striking party must articulate its reasons, and the court evaluates those reasons from the perspective of an objectively reasonable observer who is aware of implicit and institutional bias.
Perhaps most significantly, the statute identifies several commonly cited reasons for striking jurors that are now considered presumptively invalid unless supported by clear and convincing evidence. These include justifications based on demeanor, body language, apparent inattentiveness, dress, neighborhood, or other reasons historically associated with implicit bias.
Important Considerations for FEHA Cases
Employment cases brought under the Fair Employment and Housing Act (FEHA) often involve sensitive issues concerning discrimination, retaliation, harassment, disability, race, gender, age, and other protected classifications. As a result, jury selection in FEHA cases carries unique strategic considerations.
Attorneys should anticipate that opposing counsel may be more willing to challenge peremptory strikes under section 231.7, particularly when prospective jurors belong to protected groups or when commonly used explanations could be viewed as relying upon stereotypes or implicit bias.
Counsel should also remember that reasons historically accepted under Batson/Wheeler may no longer satisfy section 231.7's objective standard.
Trial lawyers should be prepared to articulate case-specific, well-supported reasons for exercising peremptory challenges and avoid relying on generalized observations that may now be deemed presumptively invalid.
Preparing for Voir Dire
For attorneys handling FEHA and other civil jury trials, preparation now extends well beyond developing voir dire questions. Practitioners should review section 231.7 before trial, carefully evaluate the basis for each peremptory challenge, and create a clear record explaining legitimate, case-specific reasons whenever appropriate.
As California courts continue interpreting section 231.7, attorneys should expect additional appellate guidance that will further define how these objections are evaluated in practice. Until then, understanding the Legislature's intent—and staying informed about emerging case law—will remain critical to effective jury selection.
At McGonigle Law, we continue to monitor significant developments affecting California trial practice and employment litigation. We encourage our colleagues to stay current on section 231.7 as this important area of civil procedure continues to evolve.
For more information or to schedule a confidential, free consultation, contact McGonigle Law at (800) 713-5260.
This newsletter is for informational purposes only and is not legal advice. Every case is unique, and past results do not guarantee future outcomes.
Your Attorney Failed You. Don't Let the Clock Run Out Too.
California's statute of limitations for legal malpractice is strict. Every day you wait is a day closer to losing your right to recover. Contact McGonigle Law today for a free, confidential consultation — we'll tell you honestly whether you have a case.

