Not Just Malpractice: The § 340.6 Trap in Attorney Fee Disputes
A recent California ruling involving more than $800,000 in alleged overbilling highlights an important issue for attorneys and clients: Code of Civil Procedure section 340.6 can apply to attorney fee disputes even when the claims are not labeled legal malpractice.

California attorneys generally associate Code of Civil Procedure section 340.6 with legal malpractice claims. But a recent Orange County Superior Court ruling provides an important reminder: the statute can reach well beyond traditional allegations of negligent legal work.
In Dykema Gossett LLP v. SCSA Group, Inc., a court dismissed a cross-complaint seeking more than $800,000 in allegedly excessive legal fees, finding the claims barred by section 340.6. The clients argued that their claims concerned billing practices—not legal malpractice. The distinction did not save the case. (Daily Journal)
The Dispute Began With an Unpaid Legal Bill
Dykema Gossett LLP sued a former corporate client to recover approximately $297,000 in unpaid legal fees. The clients responded with a cross-complaint alleging that the firm had overbilled them by more than $800,000 between 2019 and 2021.
The allegations included duplicate billing, vague time entries, undisclosed staffing, work allegedly performed outside the scope of the engagement, and inaccurate accounting of payments.
The clients maintained that they were not challenging the quality of Dykema's legal advice, advocacy, or work product. Instead, they characterized the dispute as one involving billing and disclosure practices. (Daily Journal)
Section 340.6 Is Not Limited to Negligence Claims
That distinction is where the case becomes particularly relevant to attorneys handling fee disputes.
Section 340.6 generally requires an action against an attorney arising from a wrongful act or omission in the performance of professional services to be commenced within one year after the plaintiff discovers, or reasonably should have discovered, the facts constituting the wrongful act or omission, or within four years of the wrongful act or omission, whichever occurs first, subject to statutory exceptions and tolling provisions.(California Code of Civil Procedure § 340.6)
The California Supreme Court addressed the statute's reach in Lee v. Hanley. The Court explained that section 340.6 applies when the merits of a claim necessarily depend on proof that an attorney violated a professional obligation—that is, an obligation the attorney has by virtue of being an attorney—in the course of providing professional services. (Lee v. Hanley)
That framework means the label attached to a cause of action does not necessarily control. A claim pleaded as breach of fiduciary duty, unfair billing, failure to disclose, or another theory may still fall within section 340.6 when proving it requires establishing the violation of an attorney's professional obligations.
The Clients Allegedly Knew About the Billing Issues Years Earlier
The timing proved decisive in Dykema. The court found that the clients knew or should have known of the alleged billing irregularities by 2021. Yet their cross-complaint was not filed until September 2025.
The clients' own earlier pleading reportedly alleged that Dykema's representation continued only until approximately July 2021. Based on those allegations, the court concluded that the claims were untimely under both section 340.6's one-year discovery period and its four-year outside limitation.
The court sustained Dykema's demurrer without leave to amend. (Daily Journal)
Pleading Around the Statute Did Not Work
The ruling also offers a procedural warning. The amended pleading omitted earlier allegations concerning tolling and when Dykema's representation ended. The court applied California's sham pleading doctrine and declined to allow the clients to avoid the limitations problem simply by removing unfavorable factual allegations from an earlier pleading.
The Practical Lesson for Attorneys
Fee disputes can appear deceptively different from traditional malpractice cases. A former client may challenge staffing, billing entries, fee disclosures, the scope of an engagement, or the handling of client funds without ever alleging that the attorney mishandled the underlying litigation.
But when the claim depends on an alleged violation of duties arising from the attorney-client relationship, section 340.6 may still govern.
For attorneys evaluating potential claims against prior counsel—or defending against them—the statute of limitations analysis should therefore begin with the substance of the alleged misconduct, not simply the caption placed on the causes of action.
Dykema is a useful reminder that by the time a fee dispute develops into litigation, the limitations clock may have been running for years.
McGonigle Law represents clients in legal malpractice and attorney fee disputes throughout California. For questions regarding a potential claim or referral, contact our office at (800) 713-5260.
This blog is for informational purposes only and is not legal advice. Every case is unique, and past results do not guarantee future outcomes.
Your Attorney Failed You. Don't Let the Clock Run Out Too.
California's statute of limitations for legal malpractice is strict. Every day you wait is a day closer to losing your right to recover. Contact McGonigle Law today for a free, confidential consultation — we'll tell you honestly whether you have a case.

