What Happens When A Private Disability Insurance Claim Is Denied

This article explains what to do after a disability insurance claim is denied, including reviewing the denial letter and policy, determining whether ERISA applies, gathering medical and vocational evidence, meeting appeal deadlines, challenging insurer medical reviews, and considering litigation when benefits remain unpaid.

22 Dec 2022

A denial of disability insurance benefits can create immediate financial pressure, but a denial is not necessarily the end of the claim.

The next step depends on the type of disability coverage, the reason for denial, the policy language, and the deadlines that apply.

What Is Disability Insurance?

Disability insurance replaces part of a person’s income when illness or injury prevents them from performing work covered by the policy.

Private Disability Policy vs. Employer-Sponsored ERISA Plan

Individually purchased disability policies and employer-sponsored ERISA plans can involve very different appeal procedures, remedies, and litigation strategies.

Step 1: Read the Denial Letter Carefully

Identify every medical, factual, vocational, and policy-based reason the insurer gives for denying benefits.

Step 2: Obtain the Complete Policy or Plan Documents

Review the definition of disability, exclusions, limitations, appeal procedures, deadlines, benefit duration, and proof requirements.

Step 3: Determine Whether ERISA Applies

Many employer-sponsored disability plans are governed by ERISA and require completion of an administrative appeal process before litigation.

Step 4: Identify the Appeal Deadline Immediately

Many ERISA disability plans provide approximately 180 days to appeal an adverse benefit determination. Review the denial letter and governing plan documents immediately.

Step 5: Review the Insurer’s Claim File

Where available, review medical reviews, vocational analyses, claim notes, surveillance, job descriptions, and other materials relied upon by the insurer.

Step 6: Build the Medical Record

Medical evidence should explain not only the diagnosis but how symptoms and restrictions interfere with occupational duties.

Step 7: Document the Duties of Your Occupation

Preserve job descriptions, physical and cognitive requirements, schedules, supervisory obligations, travel requirements, and other evidence showing what your work actually requires.

Step 8: Consider Vocational Evidence

Vocational analysis may help connect medical restrictions to occupational demands and alternative-work questions.

Step 9: Respond to Insurer Medical Reviews

Address insurer consultants directly with updated records, physician responses, testing, functional evidence, and vocational analysis where appropriate.

Step 10: Prepare a Comprehensive Appeal

A strong appeal should address every stated reason for denial and include the medical, occupational, vocational, and policy evidence supporting disability.

Why the ERISA Administrative Record Matters

In ERISA cases, evidence submitted during the administrative process can become critical if federal litigation follows.

What If an ERISA Appeal Is Denied?

After required administrative remedies are exhausted, a claimant may potentially pursue benefits in federal court under ERISA.

What If an Individual Disability Policy Claim Is Denied?

Individual disability policies may provide different state-law remedies, potentially including contract and insurance bad-faith claims depending on the facts.

What Is Insurance Bad Faith?

Bad faith generally concerns unreasonable withholding of policy benefits or unreasonable claim handling. An incorrect denial does not automatically establish bad faith.

What About Surveillance and Social Media?

Insurers may use surveillance or publicly available information to evaluate claimed limitations, making accurate and consistent descriptions of functional capacity important.

Can Benefits Be Terminated After They Were Initially Approved?

Yes. Insurers may later terminate benefits based on medical review, policy-definition changes, surveillance, vocational analysis, or policy limitations.

Can You File a Complaint With the California Department of Insurance?

Depending on the policy and issue, the California Department of Insurance may review complaints concerning insurers and claims handling.

Is Mediation or Settlement Possible?

Some disputes resolve through appeal, negotiation, mediation, reinstatement of benefits, back benefits, or negotiated lump-sum settlements.

What Evidence Should You Preserve?

Keep the policy, denial letter, medical evidence, occupational records, vocational evidence, insurer correspondence, appeal submissions, and other claim materials.

What Should You Not Do After a Denial?

Do not ignore the denial, miss deadlines, submit an incomplete appeal, destroy relevant records, or assume missing evidence can always be added later during litigation.

When Should You Contact a Disability Insurance Attorney?

Legal advice may be especially important when an ERISA deadline is running, long-term benefits have been denied or terminated, insurer consultants disagree with treating physicians, or substantial future benefits are at stake.

McGonigle Law represents clients in disability insurance disputes involving employer-sponsored ERISA plans and individually purchased disability policies.

The information contained herein is for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.

Solutions

Your Attorney Failed You. Don't Let the Clock Run Out Too.

California's statute of limitations for legal malpractice is strict. Every day you wait is a day closer to losing your right to recover. Contact McGonigle Law today for a free, confidential consultation — we'll tell you honestly whether you have a case.

Phone icon
Phone
Email icon
Email
Location pin icon
Office