When Experts Disagree: What the Lindsay Clancy Trial Teaches About Expert Testimony
The Lindsay Clancy trial illustrates how qualified experts can review similar evidence and reach dramatically different conclusions. The case offers important lessons about expert testimony, methodology, cross-examination, and why an expert's credentials are only part of what determines the strength of an opinion.

Few things illustrate the importance of expert testimony more clearly than a case in which experienced professionals examine the same person, review much of the same history, and arrive at fundamentally different conclusions.
That dynamic has been on display in the closely watched murder trial of Lindsay Clancy, the Massachusetts mother charged in the 2023 deaths of her three young children.
The central issue is not whether Clancy killed her children. Her defense maintains that she was not criminally responsible because she was suffering from postpartum psychosis and could not conform her conduct to the law. Prosecutors have presented a markedly different interpretation of her mental condition and actions. As the case reached the jury, both sides had presented experts offering competing opinions about her mental state. (AP News)
For trial lawyers, the case provides a compelling illustration of a broader lesson: an expert's credentials may get the jury's attention, but credentials alone rarely decide which opinion the jury accepts.
Two Experts Can See the Same Evidence Differently
Defense experts included forensic psychiatrist Dr. Phillip Resnick, who concluded that Clancy suffered from bipolar disorder and postpartum psychosis. He testified that she experienced a “command hallucination” and was unable to conform her conduct to the law. Forensic psychologist Dr. Paul Zeizel also testified for the defense and discussed Clancy's reports of hearing a male voice directing her actions. (WBUR)
The prosecution's experts reached different conclusions.
Forensic psychologist Dr. Kirk Heilbrun testified that he did not believe Clancy was experiencing acute postpartum psychosis when the children were killed and concluded that she understood her actions were wrong. Forensic psychiatrist Dr. Gregory Saathoff also questioned aspects of Clancy's account, including her report that she heard a voice commanding her to kill. (AP News)
So how does a jury decide?
That is where effective expert testimony becomes much more than a résumé.
The Opinion Is Only as Strong as Its Foundation
In complex litigation, lawyers must examine not only what an expert concludes, but how the expert got there.
That means asking questions such as:
- What records did the expert review?
- When did the expert examine the individual?
- What assumptions form the basis of the opinion?
- Is the expert's experience directly relevant to the issue?
- Is the opinion consistent with contemporaneous records and witness testimony?
- How does the expert account for evidence that appears inconsistent with the conclusion?
The Clancy trial demonstrated this process in unusually public fashion.
During cross-examination, defense attorney Kevin Reddington challenged Heilbrun's experience with postpartum mental health and emphasized that his evaluation of Clancy occurred more than three years after the deaths. Prosecutors, meanwhile, scrutinized the defense experts' conclusions and highlighted perceived inconsistencies in Clancy's accounts and behavior. (WBUR)
Cross-Examination Tests More Than Credentials
A highly credentialed expert can still face a difficult cross-examination.
Experienced trial attorneys look beneath the qualifications and test the expert's methodology, assumptions, source material, consistency and potential weaknesses. Sometimes a single assumption underlying an opinion can become more consequential than pages of credentials.
That lesson extends well beyond criminal trials.
Ultimately, the expert's job is not simply to have an opinion. It is to provide a well-supported opinion that can withstand scrutiny and help the factfinder understand an issue outside ordinary experience.
The Clancy trial is a sobering reminder of just how consequential that process can become.
Read More
For readers interested in following the case, these reports provide useful additional context:
- AP: What to Know About the Lindsay Clancy Murder Trial
- WBUR: Testimony Concludes in the Lindsay Clancy Trial
- WBUR: The Defense Rests in the Lindsay Clancy Murder Trial
- WBUR: Clancy Trial Highlights Postpartum Psychosis and Barriers to Care
If you need assistance with a legal matter, we are available for a free, confidential conversation. Contact McGonigle Law at (800) 713-5260.
This blog is for informational purposes only and is not legal advice. Every case is unique, and past results do not guarantee future outcomes.
Solutions
Your Attorney Failed You. Don't Let the Clock Run Out Too.
California's statute of limitations for legal malpractice is strict. Every day you wait is a day closer to losing your right to recover. Contact McGonigle Law today for a free, confidential consultation — we'll tell you honestly whether you have a case.

