Fat Face Fenners Falloon v. Lurie Zepeda Schmalz and Hogan

In 2010, restaurant operator Fat Face Fenner's Falloon filed a lawsuit against its landlord, Pierside Properties, regarding the condition of the premises and various rental charges.

May 14, 2024
Insights

In 2010, restaurant operator Fat Face Fenner's Falloon (Fat Face) filed a lawsuit against its landlord, Pierside Properties, regarding the condition of the premises and various rental charges. Pierside filed a cross-complaint seeking unpaid rent and termination of Fat Face's leases.

On the opening day of trial, the parties reached a settlement that required Fat Face to pay Pierside $25,000, and forfeit its option to renew its leases. Fat Face then filed a legal malpractice action against its attorneys, William Clark and defendant Lurie, Zepeda, Schmalz & Hogan (LZSH), regarding their handling of the litigation with Pierside.

The complaint alleged that immediately prior to the commencement of the Pierside trial, LZSH told Fat Face it was not prepared to try the case, which forced Fat Face to accept an unfavorable settlement. LZSH filed a motion for summary judgment arguing that Fat Face could not establish it would have obtained a more favorable result had the case against Pierside proceeded to trial. The trial court granted the motion.

Fat Face appeals the judgment, asserting that LZSH failed to make a prima facie showing that Fat Face could not prevail on its malpractice claim. LZSH cross-appeals the court's determination that a settlement between co-defendant William Clark and Fat Face was made in good faith. (See Code of Civ. Proc., §§ 877, 877.6.) We reverse the court's judgment, and dismiss the appeal and cross-appeal concerning the determination of good faith settlement.

A summary of Fat Face’s Litigation Against Pierside can be found in the attached document.

Related documents

311 KB

Similar Verdicts

May 14, 2024
Timothy D. McGonigle

Patel v. Gwire

Plaintiffs Rakash (Ray) Patel and the Patel Family Trust appeal from a summary judgment in a legal malpractice suit against their former attorney, William Gwire.

April 25, 2024
Timothy D. McGonigle

$6.1 Million Verdict Against Centro Medico Community Clinic For Wrongful Termination Of Whistle Blower

Clinic fired doctor who reported illegal management practices and exploitation of patients.

April 25, 2024
Timothy D. McGonigle

Timothy D. McGonigle Obtains Favorable Outcome On Behalf Of Elderly Client In Fee Claim Of $1.5 Million

Timothy D. McGonigle defended an elderly client in a lawsuit filed by the client’s former law firm to recover approximately $1.5 million in attorney’s fees and costs.

Your Attorney Failed You. Don't Let the Clock Run Out Too.

California's statute of limitations for legal malpractice is strict. Every day you wait is a day closer to losing your right to recover. Contact McGonigle Law today for a free, confidential consultation — we'll tell you honestly whether you have a case.

Phone icon
Phone
Email icon
Email
Location pin icon
Office