Tips For Hiring A Great Lawyer: Your Guide To Making The Right Choice

This article provides practical guidance for choosing an attorney, including identifying the right practice area, verifying the lawyer’s California license and disciplinary history, evaluating relevant experience, asking questions during the consultation, understanding who will handle the matter, and reviewing fees and the engagement agreement before hiring counsel.

06 Jul 2023

Choosing the right lawyer can have a significant impact on your experience navigating a legal matter. Whether you are dealing with a business dispute, employment issue, personal injury claim, legal malpractice matter, or another serious legal problem, you should understand who you are hiring, what experience the attorney brings to the matter, how the representation will work, and what it will cost.

Before hiring an attorney in California, consider these seven steps.

1. Look for Experience Relevant to Your Specific Legal Problem

Start by identifying the type of lawyer your matter actually requires.

Law is a broad profession, and an attorney who is highly experienced in one practice area may have little experience handling another.

Relevant experience is generally more informative than years in practice alone.

2. Verify the Attorney Through the California State Bar

Before hiring a California attorney, look up the lawyer through the State Bar of California.

The State Bar's attorney profile allows consumers to verify whether an attorney is licensed and currently eligible to practice law in California. It can also provide information concerning public disciplinary and administrative history.

Confirm that the lawyer's identifying information matches the person or firm you have contacted.

3. Research the Attorney's Experience and Reputation

Referrals from friends, relatives, colleagues, other attorneys, or professionals can be useful starting points, but a referral should not replace your own evaluation.

Review the lawyer's professional biography, practice areas, relevant case experience, publications, professional organizations, and other available information.

Online reviews can provide additional perspective, but they should be considered carefully and should not substitute for evaluating whether the attorney has experience relevant to your particular matter.

4. Ask the Right Questions During the Consultation

An initial consultation is an opportunity for both you and the attorney to determine whether the relationship is a good fit.

Before the meeting, organize the key facts and bring important documents relating to the matter.

  • What are the major legal issues you see?
  • What are the potential strengths and weaknesses?
  • What are the possible next steps?
  • Who will actually handle my case?
  • How will I receive updates?
  • What major deadlines may apply?
  • What will the representation cost?

Be cautious if an attorney guarantees a particular result. Litigation and other legal matters involve uncertainties that cannot always be predicted at the beginning of a representation.

5. Find Out Who Will Actually Handle Your Case

The lawyer you initially meet may not necessarily be the person performing most of the work on your matter.

Ask whether your case will primarily be handled by the attorney you are consulting with, another attorney, a team of lawyers, or other legal professionals.

If multiple attorneys will work on the matter, ask what their respective roles will be and how their time will be billed.

6. Understand the Fee Agreement and Costs

Before hiring a lawyer, understand how the firm will charge for its services.

  • Hourly fees;
  • Contingency fees;
  • Flat fees;
  • Retainers or advance deposits; or
  • A combination of fee arrangements where permitted.

Ask what the attorney fee includes and what expenses may be charged separately.

Review the written engagement agreement carefully and ask questions about anything you do not understand before signing it.

7. Pay Attention to Communication and Professional Judgment

Legal knowledge is important, but the attorney-client relationship also depends on communication and trust.

A good attorney should listen carefully, explain legal concepts clearly, answer questions directly, identify risks as well as strengths, and set realistic expectations.

Questions to Ask Before Hiring a Lawyer

  • Have you handled cases involving this type of dispute before?
  • What percentage of your practice involves this area of law?
  • Who will be primarily responsible for my case?
  • What are the likely stages of the matter?
  • How will we communicate?
  • What is your fee structure?
  • What additional case expenses might I be responsible for?
  • What significant deadlines should I know about?

Red Flags to Consider Before Hiring an Attorney

Consider asking additional questions if the lawyer guarantees a result, cannot be verified through the State Bar, will not clearly explain fees, cannot tell you who will handle the case, or pressures you to sign an agreement you do not understand.

How to Choose the Right Lawyer for You

There is no single attorney who is the right choice for every legal matter.

Take time to verify the attorney's credentials, ask detailed questions, review the engagement agreement, and understand who will be responsible for your case before making your decision.

If you have questions about a legal matter handled by McGonigle Law, contact our team to discuss your situation and determine whether our firm may be able to assist.

The information contained herein is for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.

Solutions

Your Attorney Failed You. Don't Let the Clock Run Out Too.

California's statute of limitations for legal malpractice is strict. Every day you wait is a day closer to losing your right to recover. Contact McGonigle Law today for a free, confidential consultation — we'll tell you honestly whether you have a case.

Phone icon
Phone
Email icon
Email
Location pin icon
Office