Expert Witness
Trusted Authority in Complex Legal Proceedings
When disputes over attorney malpractice or legal fees escalate into litigation, the testimony of a credible expert witness can make or break the case. Judges and juries rely on experienced voices to explain what the professional standard of care requires, whether ethical obligations were met, and whether an attorney’s conduct was consistent with accepted practices. In these moments, the credibility and clarity of an expert witness are invaluable.
With over 40 years of dedicated practice, Timothy D. McGonigle has earned a reputation as one of California’s most respected litigators in the areas of attorney malpractice and attorney fee disputes. Known for his sharp trial advocacy, ethical integrity, and deep knowledge of professional conduct rules, Timothy has become a sought-after expert witness and private consultant. His testimony brings clarity to complicated malpractice and billing disputes, and his reputation lends credibility to the cases he supports.
CLICK HERE TO SEE IF YOU QUALIFY FOR COMPENSATION
Why Timothy McGonigle Is Chosen as an Expert Witness
As a plaintiffs’ lawyer, Timothy has built a career on holding attorneys accountable when they fail their clients. He has tried—and won—numerous malpractice and fee dispute cases, securing favorable outcomes that helped shape California’s legal landscape. This practical experience allows him to do more than interpret rules—he explains how they operate in real-world practice.
Attorneys and firms across California call on Timothy not only because of his trial-tested expertise, but also because of his unwavering commitment to ethical standards. His credibility as a litigator translates seamlessly into his role as an expert witness, where neutrality, precision, and integrity are essential. Whether testifying in trial, consulting on case strategy, or reviewing billing practices, Timothy provides reliable guidance grounded in decades of success.
Providing Trial Testimony on a Broad Range of Legal Topics
Mr. McGonigle has testified at or consulted on trials regarding a wide variety of topics, including:
Standard of Care for Lawyers – Explaining what competent representation requires under California law.
Ethical Standards and Rules – Interpreting professional rules of conduct and evaluating attorney compliance.
Breach of Duty – Identifying when an attorney failed to meet professional obligations owed to a client.
Best Practices – Outlining accepted industry practices for managing cases, clients, and litigation strategy.
Attorney Fees and Billing Practices – Assessing whether fees charged were fair, reasonable, and consistent with ethical obligations.
His testimony provides courts with the framework needed to evaluate complex attorney conduct issues, bridging the gap between professional standards and real-world practice.
Private Consultation for Firms and Clients
In addition to expert witness testimony, Timothy provides private consultation services for firms, clients, and counsel seeking insight on malpractice and fee dispute cases. His input helps legal teams refine their arguments, evaluate risks, and prepare for trial with a clear understanding of how professional standards will be viewed in court.
Timothy’s role as a consultant is rooted in the same principles that guide his litigation work: precision, clarity, and integrity. By offering strategic insights before trial, he helps firms strengthen their cases and avoid pitfalls that could weaken their position.
A Reputation Built on Integrity
Throughout his four decades in practice, Timothy has been recognized not only for his skill in the courtroom, but also for his ethical integrity and professionalism. These qualities are what make him such a powerful expert witness. Judges and juries respond to his testimony because it is grounded in real experience, delivered with clarity, and backed by an unassailable reputation in California’s legal community.
Engage Timothy McGonigle as an Expert Witness
If you require the expertise of a seasoned litigator and trusted expert witness, Timothy D. McGonigle stands ready to assist. Whether providing trial testimony, consulting on malpractice or fee disputes, or guiding strategy behind the scenes, Timothy brings unmatched credibility and insight to every case.
👉 To schedule a consultation, call 1-800-713-5260 or complete our confidential intake form.
CLICK HERE TO SEE IF YOU QUALIFY FOR COMPENSATION
Frequently Asked Questions About Expert Witness Services
Q1: What is the role of an expert witness in a legal malpractice case?
An expert witness explains the professional standards attorneys must follow and gives an opinion on whether a lawyer’s conduct fell below those standards. Their testimony helps judges and juries understand complex legal obligations.
Q2: Why do I need an expert witness in an attorney malpractice case?
In most malpractice cases, proving negligence requires expert testimony. Without it, courts may dismiss claims because the jury lacks the specialized knowledge to evaluate an attorney’s performance.
Q3: What makes Timothy McGonigle qualified as an expert witness?
With over 40 years of litigation experience in attorney malpractice and fee disputes, Timothy combines practical courtroom knowledge with a reputation for integrity and professionalism. His credibility makes his testimony highly persuasive.
Q4: Can Timothy serve as an expert witness for both plaintiffs and defendants?
Yes. Timothy has provided testimony and consultation for both sides in malpractice and fee disputes, offering balanced and objective insights grounded in ethical standards.
Q5: What types of topics does Timothy testify about?
Standards of care for attorneys.
Ethical rules and compliance.
Breach of duty and conflicts of interest.
Best practices in case management.
Reasonable attorney fees and billing practices.
Q6: How does an expert witness help in fee dispute cases?
An expert can analyze billing records, evaluate whether fees are reasonable and ethical, and testify about proper billing practices. This testimony often determines whether disputed fees are reduced or refunded.
Q7: How does expert witness testimony influence a jury?
Jurors rely heavily on expert testimony to understand technical issues. A credible expert like Timothy provides clarity, context, and authority that can strongly shape outcomes in malpractice and fee disputes.
Q8: Can Timothy provide consultation without testifying?
Yes. Many firms engage Timothy privately to review cases, advise on trial strategy, or prepare attorneys for cross-examination. His insights can strengthen a case even if he never takes the stand.
Q9: What is the difference between consulting and testifying as an expert?
A consulting expert advises the legal team privately, and their work is typically confidential. A testifying expert presents opinions in court, subject to disclosure and cross-examination. Timothy offers both services.
Q10: How are expert witnesses compensated?
Experts are typically paid for their time reviewing records, preparing opinions, and testifying in court. These costs are often critical investments in malpractice or fee dispute litigation.
Q11: Does every legal malpractice case require an expert witness?
Most do, especially when evaluating an attorney’s standard of care. Exceptions may occur when negligence is obvious—such as a missed filing deadline—but even then, expert testimony can strengthen the case.
Q12: How do I engage Timothy as an expert witness?
You can call 1-800-713-5260 or complete our confidential intake form to schedule a consultation. We’ll discuss your case, determine whether expert testimony is appropriate, and outline next steps.
To schedule an appointment with one of our attorneys, please call us at 1-800-713-5260 or by completing our intake form.
